Comparison

Best Diamond Testers 2026: Pen Testers to Lab-Grown Screeners, Compared

Every diamond tester and lab-grown screener we stock, compared by what it detects, who it suits and what it costs: Presidium, GemTrue, Gemlogis, Gemetrix, DRC and more.

OTI by Presidium diamond tester
In this guide

    Quick answer: For a retail counter, start with a dual thermal-electrical pen tester such as the GemTrue Multi Experior or Presidium Multi Tester III to catch moissanite. If you handle goods where lab-grown stones are a risk, add a screener: the GemTrue Veritas or Presidium SDS-II at the entry level, or a DRC system if you test mounted jewellery at volume. No single instrument answers every question.

    We supply diamond testers to jewellers, buyers and labs from our Bangkok showroom, and the question we hear most has not changed in twenty years: which tester should I buy? The honest answer depends on which of two very different questions you need the instrument to answer. This guide compares every tester and screener we currently stock, grouped by the job they do.

    The two questions a tester can answer

    The first question is: is this stone a diamond at all? Thermal and electrical pen testers answer it in seconds, separating diamond from moissanite, CZ and glass. The second question is: is this diamond natural or lab-grown? No pen tester can answer that, because CVD and HPHT lab-grown stones are real diamonds with identical thermal and electrical behaviour. That job belongs to a screener, which reads how the stone responds to ultraviolet light and sorts it into pass or refer. Our tester vs screener guide covers the science; here we compare the instruments.

    Entry level: pen testers for the counter (under ฿10,000)

    These answer the first question fast and fit in a drawer.

    • GemTrue Multi Experior: the value pick. Dual thermal and electrical testing separates diamond from moissanite in one touch, with a simple readout that counter staff learn in minutes.
    • Presidium Multi Tester III (PMuT III): the trade classic. The same dual-conductivity approach from the best-known name in handheld testing, with Presidium's metal-alert feature to flag accidental contact with the setting.
    • Gemlogis Astro: goes beyond diamond. A touchscreen tester that identifies diamond, moissanite and 29 coloured gemstone types by thermal signature, useful when mixed parcels cross your counter.
    • Presidium Gem Tester II: the coloured-stone specialist. Distinguishes diamonds and moissanite plus around 16 common coloured gems, a long-standing favourite with appraisers.

    Mid range: lab-grown screeners (฿15,000 to ฿40,000)

    These answer the second question: natural or possibly lab-grown. All UV-based screeners return pass or refer, and a refer result means send the stone for confirmation, not that it is synthetic. That behaviour is normal and is how the technology protects you.

    • GemTrue Veritas CVD/HPHT: the newest screener from GemTrue and the most affordable route to lab-grown screening on this list.
    • Gemetrix Melee Inspector: built for the small-stone problem. Screens melee parcels, where lab-grown contamination is hardest to catch stone by stone.
    • Presidium SDS-II: Presidium's desktop screener, separating natural diamonds from potential CVD/HPHT in a simple pass/refer workflow.
    • Gemetrix DOVE: a compact deep-UV detector for lab-grown diamond screening, versatile across loose and parcel work.
    • ARI by Presidium: a handheld verification instrument for identifying natural diamonds against lab-grown, built for jewellers who want screening in pen-tester form.
    • GemTrue APEX 5-in-1: one instrument for both questions. Separates natural diamond, CVD and HPHT lab-grown, moissanite and simulants with a touchscreen and USB-C charging; the strongest all-rounder in this bracket.
    • Gemlogis Belize Pro: dual thermal and optical probes cover the moissanite question and the CVD/HPHT question in a single handheld.

    Pocket screening for buyers (฿75,000)

    The Gemometrics Gem Pen sits in its own category: a filter-based pocket instrument that flags HPHT and CVD lab-grown stones instantly during buying trips. It is a triage tool rather than a desktop screener, and buyers who inspect goods away from their desk carry it precisely because it fits in a shirt pocket.

    Professional systems: volume and mounted goods (฿160,000+)

    When testing is part of your production line rather than an occasional check, the DRC systems are what sorting houses and labs in Bangkok actually run.

    • SENTINEL by DRC: a compact AI-powered detection system for fast screening of natural against lab-grown at desk scale.
    • GUARDIAN PRO by DRC: a high-throughput detector built for businesses screening serious volume.
    • J-Detect Pro by DRC: the flagship. Better than 98 percent accuracy identifying CVD, HPHT and treated diamonds, in loose stones and, critically, in mounted jewellery, which most screeners cannot handle. Results in 45 to 90 seconds.

    Comparison at a glance

    Instrument Price tier Detects Best for
    GemTrue Multi Experior Entry Diamond vs moissanite/simulants First tester, counter checks
    Presidium Multi Tester III Entry Diamond vs moissanite/simulants Trade-standard counter work
    Gemlogis Astro Entry Diamond + 29 gem types Mixed stone parcels
    GemTrue Veritas Mid CVD/HPHT screening First lab-grown screener
    Presidium SDS-II Mid CVD/HPHT screening Desktop pass/refer workflow
    Gemetrix Melee Inspector Mid Lab-grown in melee Small-stone parcels
    GemTrue APEX Mid Both questions, 5-in-1 One-instrument counters
    Gemlogis Belize Pro Mid Moissanite + CVD/HPHT Handheld all-rounder
    Gemometrics Gem Pen Upper HPHT/CVD triage Buying trips
    SENTINEL / GUARDIAN PRO Pro Lab-grown at volume Sorting houses
    J-Detect Pro Pro CVD/HPHT/treated, incl. mounted Labs, estate and mounted goods

    How to choose by business type

    Retail counter: a dual pen tester, plus the APEX or a Veritas once lab-grown goods enter your market. Buyer or broker: a pen tester and the Gem Pen for the road, with refer stones confirmed at a lab. Melee sorting house: the Melee Inspector or a DRC system, verified by weight checks as described in our sieving guide. Lab or estate jeweller: J-Detect Pro, because mounted goods are where everything else gives up. Not sure? Ask our team: we test stones on these instruments daily and ship worldwide from Bangkok.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can any single tester detect both moissanite and lab-grown diamonds?

    A few combination instruments cover both questions: the GemTrue APEX separates natural diamond, CVD and HPHT lab-grown, moissanite and simulants in one unit, and the Gemlogis Belize Pro pairs thermal and optical probes for the same purpose. Classic pen testers cover only the moissanite question.

    Why do screeners say refer instead of synthetic?

    UV-based screeners sort diamonds by type, and a small share of natural diamonds share the type that lab-grown stones belong to. Refer means the stone needs laboratory confirmation. It is the honest answer the physics allows, and every reputable screener on the market works this way.

    Which tester should a small jewellery shop buy first?

    A dual thermal and electrical pen tester such as the GemTrue Multi Experior or Presidium Multi Tester III. It answers the most common counter question, is this a diamond, in seconds. Add a lab-grown screener once you trade in goods where synthetic contamination carries real cost.

    Can lab-grown diamonds be detected in mounted jewellery?

    Yes, but only by instruments designed for it. The J-Detect Pro by DRC identifies CVD, HPHT and treated diamonds in set jewellery without unmounting stones, which is why estate jewellers and labs choose it despite the professional price tag.

    Written by Kunal Jain

    Sachi Gems & Tools Co. Ltd., Bangkok. The Sachi buying guides distill what our team has learned supplying gemological instruments and jewellery tools to gem labs, jewellers and sorting houses worldwide since 2001. Questions about anything in this guide? Ask our Bangkok team.